Categories: News

The Supreme Court just handed Trump an astonishing victory

Former President Donald Trump speaks as Justice Neil Gorsuch looks on during a ceremony in the Rose Garden at the White House April 10, 2017, in Washington, DC. | Eric Thayer/Getty Images

So much for the rule of law.

The Supreme Court ruled on Wednesday that Trump’s DC criminal trial, the one concerning his attempt to steal the 2020 presidential election, must be delayed for at least another two months. The Court already effectively delayed his trial for an additional two and a half months in an order handed down last December.

This order is a colossal victory for Trump, and could potentially allow him to evade criminal responsibility for his attempts to overthrow the 2020 election altogether. Trump’s goal is to delay his trials until after Election Day. Should he prevail in that election, he can then order the Justice Department to drop all federal charges against him.

Trump was able to secure such an order from the justices by exploiting the fact that the federal judiciary ordinarily does not allow two different courts to have jurisdiction over the same case at the same time. So, when a party to a lawsuit or criminal proceeding appeals a trial court’s decision, the trial court often loses authority over that case until the appeal is resolved.

The ostensible reason for the Court’s order putting the trial on ice is that the Court needs that time to consider a weak appeal challenging a ruling by Judge Tanya Chutkan, the judge presiding over his DC criminal trial.

According to Trump, the Constitution forbids any prosecution of a former president for any “official acts” he engaged in while in office. The implications of this argument are astounding, and Trump’s lawyers haven’t exactly tried to hide them. During one court hearing, the former president’s lawyer told a judge that Trump could not be prosecuted even if he had ordered “SEAL Team 6 to assassinate a political rival,” unless Trump were also impeached and convicted by the Senate.

It’s hard to imagine the Supreme Court signing onto this argument, which has already been rejected by two other courts.

Yet Trump has now, with Wednesday’s ruling, leveraged this ridiculous legal argument to delay his DC trial for at least four and a half months, and the delay will likely extend much longer because the Court will need time to produce an opinion. The Court will hear oral arguments in late April.

Simply put, Wednesday’s order is a disaster for anyone hoping that Trump may face trial before the November election. And, because the nominal reason for this order is to give the justices more time to decide if the president is completely above the law, this decision raises serious doubts about whether this Court can be trusted to oversee Trump-related cases in a nonpartisan manner.

Vox - Huntsville Tribune

Recent Posts

3 winners and 2 losers from the Harris-Trump debate

Vice President Kamala Harris shakes hands with former President Donald Trump during a presidential debate…

44 mins ago

How Kamala Harris goaded (and goaded and goaded) Trump into a debate trainwreck

Vice President Kamala Harris during the second presidential debate in Philadelphia, on September 10, 2024.…

2 hours ago

Tyreek Hill’s disturbing detention by police, explained

Tyreek Hill on the sidelines during an NFL preseason football game against the Tampa Bay…

7 hours ago

Apple’s new AI is magically mediocre

Apple announced that its new AI technology would be available in October at an event…

9 hours ago

Yet another person got bird flu. Now should I freak out?

Last Friday, the Missouri health department announced a recent human case of bird flu. What’s…

11 hours ago

The sprawling ecosystem of Reddit’s Am I the Asshole

It’s the stories that draw people in: A bride feeling upstaged on her wedding day;…

19 hours ago