The propaganda package basically skips from January to March. That’s not an accident.
A campaign-style video President Donald Trump is promoting in an attempt to rewrite the history of his coronavirus response accidentally reveals the truth — that he didn’t really do much during a crucial period in February and early March when the virus was spreading undetected in America, besides downplaying the threat.
The video, which premiered during Monday’s unhinged White White coronavirus task force briefing and was then posted to Trump’s Twitter account, features a timeline of what the video refers to as the president’s “DECISIVE ACTION” during that period. But the list of Trump’s anti-coronavirus actions is far shorter than it might appear as it ticks by your screen.
For one thing, Trump had little to do with a number of the “actions” highlighted in the timeline. For another, the video includes a number of developments that are really nothing to brag about, such as the first US case being reported on January 20 and the CDC testing debacle that put the US behind the curve compared to other countries that have more successfully handled the coronavirus. And it skips right from early February to March, thereby revealing Trump didn’t do much during a period in which proactive measures could’ve been taken, saving lives and ensuring the country didn’t need to practice the sort of drastic social distancing we’re now enduring in a last-ditch effort to slow the spread.
The timeline of Trump’s “DECISIVE ACTION” in this video is so sad. The only pre-March thing he can take credit for is restricting travel from China (after virus was already spreading).
It highlights 1st reported case & CDC testing debacles as if those are things to brag about! pic.twitter.com/vbshDWJoFU
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) April 14, 2020
Here are some of the things mentioned in the timeline, followed briefly by the ways they actually illuminate the administration’s failings:
- January 7: The CDC established a Covid-19 response team to track cases in the US. It’s unclear if Trump had anything to do with this — in fact, in early January, the president was ignoring classified briefings warning that the coronavirus had the potential to turn into a pandemic.
- January 20: The first reported case of Covid-19 in the US. This isn’t something to brag about, and is something Trump downplayed during an interview with CNBC two days later, saying, “It’s one person coming in from China, and we have it under control. It’s going to be just fine.”
- January 31: President Trump announces travel restrictions from China. This is one thing that Trump can take credit for — but the fact of the matter is the virus was already spreading within US borders by this time, so at best, the travel restrictions bought the federal government time that it didn’t use particularly well.
- February 6: The CDC ships the first testing kits. These were the testing kits that didn’t function properly and as a result, gave US officials little visibility into how the virus was spreading — so again, this isn’t really something to brag about.
- March 2: Pharmaceutical companies begin developing a potential vaccine. It’s unclear why Trump deserves credit for this.
- March 11: President Trump announces travel restrictions from Europe. These restrictions were implemented in such a chaotic manner that a number of airports in the US became packed with travelers desperately trying to make their way back from Europe — situations that in and of themselves created public health problems.
- March 13: President Trump declares a national emergency. By this point, the virus had already spread so widely that the social distancing guidelines Trump recommended three days later were inevitable.
That’s a pretty underwhelming set of actions. And what the video doesn’t include are all the statements Trump made between January and March downplaying the coronavirus — such as his February 26 comment that “when you have 15 [coronavirus cases], and the 15 within a couple of days is going to be down to close to zero, that’s a pretty good job we’ve done.” Or his comment the next day that the virus would go away on its own “like a miracle.”
As of April 14, the US now has more than 587,000 confirmed cases and over 23,500 Covid-19 related deaths. Now, instead of saying coronavirus will magically go away, Trump has tried to redefine success as keeping the death toll under 100,000.
Later Monday, the Trump campaign followed up on the campaign-style video (one that was apparently produced by White House staff) by posting a list of Trump’s coronavirus accomplishments including similarly dubious things, like Trump mentioning the virus during the State of the Union and him talking about it with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi during a February trip.
Look at the things that made the list of Trumps COVID19 achievements just released by the Trump campaign. pic.twitter.com/h6UmmlV1IL
— Josh Marshall (@joshtpm) April 14, 2020
But instead of being focused on the coronavirus during that India trip, upon his February 26 return, Trump reportedly chastised a number of government officials over the CDC’s February 25 warning that the virus might cause “severe” disruption to American life — not because he thought the analysis was inaccurate, but because it hurt the stock market.
Up is down
Heading into a tough reelection contest against former Vice President Joe Biden, Trump is hoping to turn weakness into strength by convincing people that, unlike some in the media, he took the coronavirus seriously from the beginning.
The reality, of course, is that Trump was unprepared. He disbanded the White House’s pandemic preparedness team in 2018, ignored warnings from his top advisers in January and February that the coronavirus could be devastating to the US economy and kill a million or more people, and engaged in wishful thinking until the last possible moment that the coronavirus would miraculously disappear without doing damage to the US economy.
Trump’s meltdown on Monday — and seemingly, his “accomplishments” video — was a reaction to an in-depth story the New York Times published over the weekend that examines his coronavirus failures in-depth. The piece is packed with documents, email threads, and on-and-off-the-record quotes from government officials — but instead of responding to it on the merits, Trump spent the weekend accusing the Times of fabricating sources.
When the Failing @nytimes or Amazon @washingtonpost writes a story saying “unnamed sources said”, or any such phrase where a person’s name is not used, don’t believe them. Most of these unnamed sources don’t exist. They are made up to defame & disparage. They have no “source”…
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) April 11, 2020
At this late date, it’s no longer a surprise that Trump is fundamentally incapable of being accountable for anything. (Monday’s briefing came on the one-month anniversary of his proclamation on the state of the US coronavirus crisis: “I don’t take responsibility for anything at all.”) But the new coronavirus timeline video illustrates both the brazenness of Trump’s attempt to rewrite history and the sheer laziness of it. It tries to create the optics of action, but a close look at the things being highlighted as accomplishments reveals there’s really nothing there beyond bluster.
Support Vox’s explanatory journalism
Every day at Vox, we aim to answer your most important questions and provide you, and our audience around the world, with information that has the power to save lives. Our mission has never been more vital than it is in this moment: to empower you through understanding. Vox’s work is reaching more people than ever, but our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources — particularly during a pandemic and an economic downturn. Your financial contribution will not constitute a donation, but it will enable our staff to continue to offer free articles, videos, and podcasts at the quality and volume that this moment requires. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today.
Author: Aaron Rupar